LMS: lack of interactivity, but Google+ is coming
24 July 2011I have an experience of working with Blackboard as both a student and as a TA. Honestly, I never really thought of either advantages or disadvantages of this platform as a learning tool but rather took it the way it is. Now, after exploring and experiencing (most of the time just with the purpose of checking the platform out), I can see why more and more academics (both students and professors) are turning away from Blackboard. It’s too “not engaging” and too standard platform, which makes students feel alienated from the educational process. I think that the major drawback of the LMS such as Blackboard is contained in its structure and users’ opportunities. You can not share video or audio information there, customize your personal pages, engage other platforms such as social media, for instance.
In terms of other LMS versions, I’ve found Canvas more attractive than Blackboard, and it gives you an opportunity to use images, video and other types of files as well as allows to embed facebook, twitter, delicious, blog and some other social media platforms in it. I think initially, it might be a bit complicated for educators without computer / technical skills to figure out how the Canvas works and how to set up the pages and use all of it options. But with a well structured and easy written guide, Canvas might become a good alternative to Blackboard. Unfortunately, for some reason mySakai couldn’t be installed (I tried twice, but it didn’t read my login and password), but I’ve watched the introduction video, and it seems like mySakai is a very nice and convenient software. I’m not sure if you can share video information there, but if yes – I would go for it instead of Blackboard for sure. Now, Moodle. Although I’m not a fan of yellow color
, I liked some of the Moodle sites (yes, u can change the theme with another color combinations). It’s hard to see the advantages/disadvantages of either one of the platforms without using them, just by first sight. But it’s a good thing that there are different options for using LMS. I would focus on choosing a LMS platform that allows for interactivity and is user-friendly.
I absolutely agree with both Josephine and Margaux about the potential of Google+ as a learning platform. The advantages of Google+ against Facebook (which are very well articulated in the article that Josephine emailed to us) plus the high level of interactivity that is allowed within this platform make Google + a very strong alternative to standard LMS. I say “yes” to it